|
NEWS
ABOUT THE SFC
WHAT IS SEXUAL FREEDOM?
CAMPAIGNS
POLITICS
CONFERENCES
LEGAL ADVICE
SEX INFORMATION
HISTORY
GALLERY
TUPPY'S COLUMN
ARCHIVES
WHO WE ARE
CONTACT
LINKS
SFC
MYSPACE PAGE
site
designed and maintained by Lurid
Films
Hosted by Lovenet
Sponsored by World
Sex News
|
|
SPANNER TRUST ON THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE BILL
|
-
On 26th June, the UK Government finally published the Criminal
Justice and Immigration Bill 2007 (CJB). Sections 64-66 lay
out plans to criminalise possession of "extreme pornography"
- in terms even more sweeping than those of the original Home
Office consultation document.
Rather than actions, the proposed law is aimed specifically
against pictures. Regardless of what is actually shown, what
"appears to be" shown will determine the legality
of an image. As well as necrophilia and bestiality, this includes
acts which "threaten or appear to threaten a person's
life" or "result in or appear to result (or be likely
to result) in a serious injury to a person's anus, breasts
or genitals".
Coupled with the stricture that images must be "pornographic"
in order to qualify as illegal, this means that you can watch
all the gruesome cop show murders you like, but if you like
pornography of consensual fisting - which could cause serious
injury if not done with due care - you risk a three-year jail
sentence.
BBFC classification of your favourite porn may or may not
help you. You are safe watching sexual violence on an 18-certificate
DVD, for example the ball-busting scene in James Bond: Casino
Royale. However, if "the image was extracted" -
i.e. you have made a screen grab or a clip - then you could
be guilty of possessing extreme pornography.
This is demonstrably ludicrous, and the Government actually
admits in the notes on the CJB that it "constitutes an
interference" with the European Convention of Human Rights.
However, it is necessary, we are told, "for the protection
of morals".
Part of this "protection of morals" is a blatant
attempt to clamp down on the BDSM community. In spite of bland
assurances during the consultation process that the proposals
were not intended to target anyone in particular, the actual
bill drops this pretence, and explicitly refers to the Spanner
trial (R v. Brown and Others) as an example of activities
that are illegal in themselves and will now become illegal
to film or photograph.
What can be done at this stage? Well, the CJB has so far only
had its first reading, which essentially means that MPs now
know what's in it and can think it over before the second
reading and a debate followed by a vote, which is expected
by mid-July.
Although the CJB, which totals 245 pages of repressive measures
on a whole raft of topics, is unlikely to be thrown out in
its entirety, there is scope for the amendment or rejection
of certain parts at this stage.
That makes this a particularly good time to write to your
MP and express your views. Given the size of the bill, an
MP who has received no letters opposing the "extreme
pornography" sections is unlikely to even notice them.
But an MP who has received one letter might start thinking
about the issue; and an MP who has received 20 may well take
the time to read the small print and realise just how unworkable
this part of the legislation is.
If you need help finding your MP or constructing a letter
then please visit the BACKLASH website: www.backlash-uk.org.uk
- Backlash is leading the campaign against the proposed law
with the full support of the Spanner Trust.
If you live in the UK please also consider signing an online
petition against the law at http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/extreme-images/
The Government's success with this measure so far relies on
decent people seeing the words "extreme pornography"
and simply thinking "well, with a name like that, of
course it must be bad". Backlash and the Spanner Trust
are questioning this assumption as loudly as we can; every
voice helps.
WHAT IS THE SPANNER TRUST DOING?
It can be hard to believe sometimes, but it is still illegal
to engage in any consensual activities for sexual pleasure
in England, Wales or Northern Ireland which result in an injury
which is more than "transient or trifling". (Scotland
has a separate legal system where consent is generally a defence
but not in all circumstances.)
The phrase "transient or trifling" has not been
defined by the courts, but if your consensual activities result
in bruises, cuts, welts, burns, grazes, scabs, bloodshot eyes
or any other injury for sexual pleasure then you may well
have broken the law.
The Spanner Trust was set up to look after the defence fund
for the original defendants in the "Spanner" trial
(R v. Brown and Others). Over a decade later the Trust is
still working to try to change the law and also provide assistance
to anyone in the UK in trouble because of their SM activities.
Sadly that's a steady stream of people.
Your private consensual kinky activities can lead to you losing
your job, having videos and magazines seized by HM Revenue
and Customs, your home computer taken by the police, losing
custody of your children and of course, arrest and threat
of prosecution. And that's still happening to SM players,
even in 2007.
The Spanner Trust plans to bring a UK High Court application
under the Human Rights Act 1998 to allow consent as a defence
where injury occurs during activities for sexual pleasure.
For our challenge to succeed we need two things:
claimants (people willing to put their name to the application
saying that they are at risk of prosecution) and money to
help pay for the costs of the case. We are working with a
Senior Queen's Counsel who has advised us that if we manage
to bring the case to the High Court we stand a good chance
of success.
However, we need to be prepared to pay the costs of the case,
if necessary, and that could be as much as £250,000.
If you have money from a fundraiser that you would like to
forward to the Trust in pounds, dollars or euros, or you would
like to make a private donation, please go to www.spannertrust.org/donations.asp
or send a cheque to the Spanner Trust, Norvin House, 45-55
Commercial Street, London E1 6BD, UK.
If you would like to invite us to speak at your club or gathering
please email info (at) spannertrust.org
If you know anyone who would like to receive this letter as
an email please ask them to write to subscribe (at) spannertrust.org
to be added to the mailing list.
Finally, if you know anyone in the UK in trouble because of
their SM activities please ask them to email info (at) spannertrust.org
and we will do our best to help, or put them in touch with
a legal professional in their area.
-
- Thank
you again for all your support, it's much appreciated.
-
- Best
wishes, Derek Cohen
Spanner Trust Chairman
|
|
|